This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.A Tutorial Problems
These are tutorial problems intended for self-assessment of the course
understanding.
A.1 Tutorial problems I
All spaces are complex, unless otherwise specified.
1 Show that ||f||=|f(0)|+sup|f′(t)| defines a norm
on C1[0,1], which is the space of (real) functions on [0,1] with
continuous derivative.
2 Show that the formula ⟨ (xn),(yn)⟩ =∑n=1∞xnyn/n2 defines
an inner product on l∞, the space of bounded (complex)
sequences. What norm does it produce?
3 Use the Cauchy–Schwarz inequality for a suitable inner product to prove that
for all f ∈
C[0,1]
the inequality
⎪
⎪
⎪
⎪ | | f(x)x d x | ⎪
⎪
⎪
⎪ |
≤ C | ⎛
⎜
⎜
⎝ | | |f(x)|2 d x | ⎞
⎟
⎟
⎠ | |
holds for some constant
C>0
(independent of f) and find the smallest possible C
that holds for all functions f
(hint: consider the cases of equality).
4
We define the following norm on l∞, the space of
bounded complex sequences:
Show that this norm makes l∞ into a Banach space (i.e., a complete
normed space).
5
Fix a vector (
w1,…,
wn)
whose components are strictly positive real numbers, and define
an inner product on ℂ
n by
Show that this makes ℂ
n into a Hilbert space (i.e., a complete
inner-product space).
A.2 Tutorial problems II
6 Show that the supremum norm on C[0,1] isn’t given by an
inner product, by finding a counterexample to the parallelogram law.
7 In l2 let e1=(1,0,0,…),
e2=(0,1,0,0,…), e3=(0,0,1,0,0,…), and so on.
Show that Lin (e1,e2,…)=c00, and that CLin (e1,e2,…)=l2. What is CLin (e2,e3,…)?
8 Let C[−1,1]
have the standard L2 inner product,
defined by
Show that the functions 1
, t and t2−1/3
form an
orthogonal (not orthonormal!) basis for the subspace P2 of
polynomials of degree at most 2
and hence calculate the best
L2-approximation of the function t4 by polynomials in
P2.
9 Define an inner product on C[0,1]
by
Use the Gram–Schmidt process to find the first 2 terms of an
orthonormal sequence formed by orthonormalising the sequence 1
,
t, t2, …. 10 Consider the plane P in ℂ4 (usual inner
product) spanned by the vectors (1,1,0,0) and (1,0,0,−1).
Find orthonormal bases for P and P⊥, and verify
directly that (P⊥)⊥=P.
A.3 Tutorial Problems III
11 Let a and b be arbitrary
real numbers with a < b. By using the fact that
the functions 1/√2πeinx, n ∈ ℤ,
are orthonormal in L2[0,2π], together with the change of variable
x=2π(t−a)/(b−a), find an orthonormal basis in L2[a,b]
of the form en(t)=α ei n λ t, n ∈ ℤ, for suitable real constants
α and λ.
12
For which real values of α
is the Fourier series
of a function in L2[−π,π]
?
13 Calculate the Fourier series of
f(
t)=
et on [−π,π]
and use Parseval’s
identity to deduce that
14 Using the fact that (
en)
is a complete
orthonormal system in L2[−π,π]
, where
en(
t)=exp(
int)/√
2π, show that
e0,
s1,
c1,
s2,
c2,…
is a complete orthonormal
system, where sn(
t)=sin
nt/√
π and
cn(
t)= cos
nt/√
π.
Show that
every L2[−π,π]
function f has a Fourier series
converging in
the L2 sense, and give
a formula for the coefficients.
15 Let C(T)
be the space of continuous (complex)
functions on the circle
T={
z ∈ ℂ: |
z|=1 }
with the supremum norm.
Show that, for any polynomial f(
z)
in C(T)
Deduce that the function f(
z)=
z is not
the
uniform limit of polynomials on the circle (i.e., Weierstrass’s
approximation theorem doesn’t hold in this form).
A.4 Tutorial Problems IV
16 Define a linear functional on C[0,1] (continuous functions
on [0,1]) by α(f)=f(1/2). Show that α is
bounded if we give C[0,1] the supremum norm. Show that
α is not bounded if we use the L2 norm, because we can
find a sequence (fn) of continuous functions on [0,1] such
that ||fn||2 ≤ 1, but fn(1/2) → ∞.
17 The Hardy space H2 is the Hilbert space of all power series
f(
z)=∑
n=0∞an zn, such that ∑
n=0∞|
an|
2 < ∞
, where the inner product is given by
⟨
⟨
⟨
⟨ | | anzn, | | bnzn | ⟩
⟩
⟩
⟩ | = | | an | | . |
Show that the sequence 1,
z,
z2,
z3, …
is an orthonormal basis for H2.Fix w with |w|<1 and define a linear functional on H2 by
α(f)=f(w). Write down a formula for the function g(z) ∈
H2 such that α(f)=⟨ f, g ⟩. What is
||α||?
18 The Volterra operator
V:
L2[0,1] →
L2[0,1]
is defined by
Use the Cauchy–Schwarz inequality to show that |(
Vf)(
x)| ≤
√
x||
f||
2 (hint: write (
Vf)(
x)=⟨
f,
Jx⟩
where
Jx is a function that you can write down explicitly).Deduce that ||Vf||22 ≤ 1/ 2||f||22, and hence ||V||
≤ 1/√2.
19 Find the adjoints of the following operators:-
A:l2 → l2, defined by
A(x1,x2,…)=(0,x1 / 1, x2/ 2, x3/ 3,
…);
and, on a general Hilbert space H:
- The rank-one operator R, defined by Rx=⟨ x,y ⟩
z, where y and z are fixed elements of H;
- The projection operator PM, defined by PM(m+n)=m,
where m ∈ M and n ∈ M⊥, and H=M ⊕ M⊥ as
usual.
20
Let U ∈
B(
H)
be a unitary operator. Show that (
Uen)
is an orthonormal basis of H whenever (
en)
is.Let l2(ℤ) denote the Hilbert space of
two-sided sequences (an)n=−∞∞ with
Show that
the bilateral right shift, V:l2(ℤ)
→ l2(ℤ) defined by V((an))=(bn),
where bn=an−1 for all n∈ ℤ, is unitary,
whereas the usual right shift S on
l2=l2(ℕ) is not unitary.
A.5 Tutorial Problems V
21
Let f∈
C[−π,π]
and let
Mf be the multiplication operator on L2(−π,π)
,
given by (
Mfg)(
t)=
f(
t)
g(
t)
, for g ∈
L2(−π,π)
.
Find a function f′ ∈
C[−π,π]
such that
Mf*=
Mf′.Show that Mf is always a normal operator. When is it Hermitian? When is it
unitary?
22 Let T be any operator such that Tn=0
for some integer n (such
operators are called nilpotent). Show that
I−
T is invertible (hint: consider I+
T+
T2+…+
Tn−1).
Deduce that I−
T/λ
is invertible for any λ ≠ 0
.What is σ(T)? What is r(T)?
23
Let (λ
n)
be a fixed bounded sequence of complex numbers,
and define an operator on l2 by T((
xn))=((
yn))
, where
yn=λ
nxn for each n. Recall that T is a bounded operator and
||
T||=||(λ
n)||
∞. Let Λ={λ
1,λ
2,…}
.
Prove the following:-
Each λk is an eigenvalue of T, and hence is in
σ(T).
- If λ ∉Λ, then the inverse of
T−λ I exists (and is bounded).
Deduce that σ(T)=Λ. Note, that then any
non-empty compact set could be a spectrum of some bounden operator.
24
Let S be an isomorphism
between Hilbert spaces H and K,
that is, S:
H →
K is a linear bijection such that S and S−1 are bounded
operators.
Suppose that T ∈
B(
H)
.
Show that T and STS−1 have the same spectrum and the same eigenvalues
(if any). 25
Define an operator U:
l2(ℤ) →
L2(−π,π)
by
U((
an))=∑
n=−∞∞an eint/√
2π.
Show that U is a bijection and an isometry, i.e.,
that ||
Ux||=||
x||
for all x ∈
l2(ℤ)
.Let V be the bilateral right shift on l2(ℤ),
the unitary operator defined on Question 20.
Let f ∈ L2(−π,π). Show that
(UVU−1f)(t)=eitf(t), and hence, using Question 24, show that
σ(V)=T, the unit circle, but
that V has no eigenvalues.
A.6 Tutorial Problems VI
26
Show that K(
X)
is a closed linear subspace of B(
X)
, and that AT and TA
are compact whenever T ∈
K(
X)
and A ∈
B(
X)
. (This means that K(
X)
is a closed
ideal of B(
X)
.)
27
Let A be a Hilbert–Schmidt operator, and let (
en)
n≥ 1
and (
fm)
m≥ 1
be orthonormal bases of A.
By writing each Aen as Aen=∑
m=1∞⟨
Aen,
fm ⟩
fm,
show that
Deduce that the quantity ||
A||
HS2=∑
n=1∞||
Aen||
2 is
independent of the choice of orthonormal basis, and that ||
A||
HS=||
A*||
HS.
(||
A||
HS is called the Hilbert–Schmidt norm of A.)
28
-
Let T∈ K(H) be a compact operator. Using
Question 26,
show that T*T and TT* are compact
Hermitian operators.
- Let (en)n≥ 1 and (fn)n ≥ 1 be orthonormal
bases of a Hilbert space H,
let (αn)n ≥ 1 be any bounded complex sequence, and
let T ∈ B(H) be an operator
defined by
Prove that T is Hilbert–Schmidt precisely when
(αn) ∈ l2.
Show that
T is a compact operator if and only if αn → 0,
and in this case write down spectral decompositions for the
compact
Hermitian operators
T*T and TT*.
29
Solve the Fredholm integral equation φ−λ
Tφ=
f,
where f(
x)=
x and
(Tφ)(x)= | | xy2 φ(y) d y (φ ∈ L2(0,1)), |
for small values of λ
by means of the Neumann series.For what values of λ does the series converge? Write down a solution
which is valid for all λ apart from one exception. What is
the exception?
30
Suppose that h is a 2π
-periodic L2(−π,π)
function with
Fourier series ∑
n=−∞∞an eint. Show that
each of the functions φ
k(
y)=
eiky, k ∈ ℤ
, is an
eigenvector of
the integral operator T on L2(−π,π)
defined by
and calculate the
corresponding eigenvalues.Now let h(t)=−log(2(1−cost)). Assuming, without proof, that h(t) has the
Fourier series
∑n ∈ ℤ, n ≠ 0 eint/|n|, use the Hilbert–Schmidt method to
solve the Fredholm equation
φ−λ Tφ=f, where f(t) has Fourier series ∑n=−∞∞cn eint and 1/λ ∉σ(T).
A.7 Tutorial Problems VII
31 Use the Gram–Schmidt algorithm to find an orthonormal basis for
the subspace X of L2(−1,1)
spanned by the functions t, t2 and
t4.Hence find the best L2(−1,1) approximation of the constant function
f(t)=1 by functions from X.
32 For n=1,2,…
let φ
n denote the linear
functional on l2 defined by
where x=(
x1,
x2,…) ∈
l2.
Use the Riesz–Fréchet theorem to calculate ||φ
n||
. 33 Let T be a bounded linear operator on a Hilbert space, and
suppose that T=
A+
iB, where
A and B are self-adjoint operators. Express T* in terms of
A and B, and hence solve for A and B in terms of T and T*.Deduce that every operator T can be written T=A+iB, where A
and B are self-adjoint, in a unique way.
Show that T is normal
if and only if AB=BA.
34 Let Pn be the subspace of L2(−π,π)
consisting of all
polynomials of degree at most n, and let Tn be the subspace
consisting of all trigonometric polynomials of the form f(
t)=∑
k=−nn ak eikt.
Calculate the spectrum of the differentiation operator D,
defined by (
Df)(
t)=
f′(
t)
, when
-
D is regarded as an operator on Pn, and
- D is regarded as an operator on Tn.
Note that both
Pn
and
Tn are finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces.
Show that Tn has an orthonormal basis of eigenvectors of D, whereas
Pn does not.
35 Use the Neumann series to solve the Volterra integral equation
φ−λ Tφ=f in L2[0,1], where λ∈ ℂ, f(t)= 1 for
all t, and
(Tφ)(x)=∫0x t2φ(t) d t. (You should be able to sum the
infinite series.)
Last modified: November 6, 2024.